Like Shattered Glass: 125 OBS (Nominees) & Another v Lend Lease Construction (Europe) Ltd and Another [2017]

A contractor was ordered to pay £14.7 million in damages following a failure of toughened glass used to clad a central London office block. The breakages were caused by the contractor’s breach of its contractual obligations to heat soak all of the glass.
Continue reading

Comments Off

Filed under Breach of contract, Contractual interpretation

Goodlife Foods Ltd v Hall Fire Protection Ltd [2017] EWHC 767 (TCC)

This is a useful decision of the Court upholding the application of a broadly drafted clause excluding property damage liability in negligence on the part of a supplier of a fire prevention mechanism which failed.  Continue reading

Comments Off

Filed under Breach of contract, Contractual interpretation, Exclusion clauses, Fires

Electronic filing from 25 April 2017 for all Rolls Building jurisdictions

From 25 April 2017 when term-time resumes, it will no longer be possible to issue claims or applications, or to file documents, on paper; all issuing and filings in any of the jurisdictions of the Rolls Building instead have to be made through the website.

The website can be accessed via this link.

 

The Rolls Building jurisdictions relevant to property damage include:

  • TCC
  • Admiralty and Mercantile Court
  • Commercial Court

the other jurisdictions (less relevant to property damage) include the Chancery Division, IPEC, Patents Court, Financial List and the Bankruptcy and Companies Court.

 

Comments Off

Filed under Procedure

Theoretical Justifications for the “Reliance Bar”: Howmet Ltd v Economy Devices Ltd.

Neil Moody QC and Timothy Killen have published an article on the decision in Howmet in the February/March edition of the Construction Law Journal (Citation (2017) 33 Const L.J. Issue 1), published by Sweet and Maxwell.

You can read it here.

Comments Off

Filed under Causation, Intervening Acts

New Courts: Business and Property Courts

From the press release on the Judiciary website:

“From June of this year, the specialist civil courts are to be known as the “Business and Property Courts of England and Wales”.

The Business and Property Courts will be the new name for England and Wales’ international dispute resolution jurisdictions and will act as a single umbrella for business specialist courts across England and Wales.

It will encompass the specialist courts and lists of the High Court:

  • the Commercial Court, (including the Admiralty Court),
  • the Technology and Construction Court (“TCC”), and
  • the courts of the Chancery Division (including those dealing with financial services, intellectual property, competition, and insolvency).

The new arrangements will preserve the familiar practices and procedures of these courts, whilst allowing for more flexible cross-deployment of judges with suitable expertise and experience to sit on appropriate business and property cases.”

 

Comments Off

Filed under Procedure

Floods and expert evidence: Oldcorn v Southern Water Services Ltd

Oldcorn v Southern Water Services Ltd [2017] EWHC 62 TCC 

This case sets clear limits on the Marcic defence and confirms that where a sewerage undertaker’s owes a private law duty of care, it may not be able to rely upon the more limited Leakey “measured” duty of care.

Continue reading

Comments Off

Filed under Causation, Duty of Care, Expert Evidence, Floods, Nuisance

Expert reliance: Wheeldon Brothers Waste Ltd v Millennium Insurance Co Ltd

Wheeldon Brothers Waste Ltd v Millennium Insurance Co Ltd [2017] EWHC 218 TCC

This case involved a fire at the Claimant’s waste processing plant. The Claimant sought to recover approximately £1.5 million in damages from the Defendant insurers. During the first CMC, the Claimant sought to prohibit the Defendant insurer from relying on their chosen fire expert, Mr Steven Braund, a forensic expert employed by Hawkins.

Continue reading

Comments Off

Filed under Causation, Expert Evidence, Fires

Amendments to Pleadings: Al Nahda Insulation Contracting LLC & Another v Tremco Illbruck Export Ltd

In Al Nahda, the TCC has maintained its strict approach to late amendments, and those which it does not consider have any real prospect of success. Continue reading

Comments Off

Filed under Particulars of Claim, Pleadings, Procedure, Statements of Case

Liability of Independent sub-contractors: Willmott Dixon Construction Ltd v Robert West Consulting Ltd.

In Willmott Dixon Construction Ltd v Robert West Consulting Ltd [2016] EWHC 3291 (TCC), Coulson J gave guidance as to the exceptions to the general rule that a main contractor cannot be liable in tort for the acts or omissions of an independent sub-contractor. He also analysed the application of those exceptions to a plea of contributory negligence. Continue reading

Comments Off

Filed under Contribution, Duty of Care, Particulars of Claim, Pleadings

2TG Damage Day 2016

Thanks to all those who attended 2TG’s Damage Day 2016. The day was a great success, with a record number of attendees.

A special thanks to the Hon. Mr Justice Coulson who delivered the keynote speech.

 Many thanks to our speakers:

  • Howard Palmer QC who spoke on the problems of causation in contract and negligence based property damages cases
  • Jessica van der Meer who spoke on knowledge of malfunction and attribution of knowledge in property damage cases
  • Sonia Nolten who spoke on the meaning of “reasonable opportunity to abate” in subsidence claims.
  • George Hilton who spoke on procedure & awards under the Party Wall Act 1996
  • Ben Hobby FCA, Dip CII, of RGL Forensics who provided the expert perspective on proving a loss of profits calculation
  • Daniel Crowley & Isabel Barter who spoke on expert evidence & the Ocensa Pipeline Group Litigation Action
  • Andrew Miller QC who spoke on the changing face of mediation in property damage claims.

You can catch some of the highlights of Damage Day 2016 on 2TG’s twitter account: @2TempleGardens

We look forward to seeing you at Damage Day 2017

Comments Off

Filed under ADR, Breach of contract, Causation, Contribution, Duty of Care, Expert Evidence, Fires, Floods, Insurance, Limitation, Natural Disaster, Nuisance, Party Walls, Procedure